Dom Thoughts: The Purity Paradox

AI art by me

The Purity Paradox

I was prompted to write this by a casual conversation in the hallway outside my apartment.  I live in a 55+ community.  One Friday evening, as I was leaving, I ran into a neighbor coming back from bingo.  I’m not kidding.  She’s a very nice lady who would fit perfectly on a poster for a nice, white-haired grandma.  In the conversation, I told her I was going out for the evening.  She explained she was getting back to relax by reading.  I asked her what she was reading.  She told me her favorite author, and I smiled while I told her I liked him, too.

What struck me was that this author writes novels about very wicked, nasty serial killers and describes their mindsets pretty explicitly.  He’s also very descriptive in the acts they commit attached to these murders.  This made me think about the interesting purity paradox I’ve witnessed all my life.  Outward appearances and, more importantly, outward actions don’t truly reflect what goes on behind closed doors or in the inner realms of a person’s mind.

My neighbor can freely talk about her love of this author and his works in socially acceptable settings. In contrast, if I told the same crowd how much I enjoy authors who write about harems, D/s dynamics, impact play, and so on, the reaction would be very different.  Her conversation is fine, while mine makes me a social pariah.

Granted, I could use the word hypocrisy, but paradox is much nicer and less confrontational.  Most of these people would justify it by saying they only “read” about such things or “listen” to them, so it doesn’t count as a lack of purity or a sign of wickedness.  Shall I quote Scripture about “lusting” or “coveting in your heart”?

Some people dress up and espouse their innocence and purity at church, then go home to read or listen to a book that interests them because of its lurid content.  Experiencing a sin vicariously doesn’t count!  It doesn’t get put down in the ledger.  They close their eyes to the paradox. 

This paradox bothers me most when it comes to household roles and domestic discipline.  More than a couple of religions are excellent at teaching women to be submissive and accept their husbands’ rules.  They teach specifics and give reasons for it.  There’s a popular book that women give to young women getting married about properly caring for and feeding their husbands.  This book goes into the specifics and reasons.  Should anyone be surprised that these women enjoy reading books with similar themes?

The problem is that there are no religions I am aware of that teach in any meaningful way how a man is supposed to lead or be the dominant role in their home.  Go lead.  Lead with God.  Follow the scriptures.  Are you sure?  Those scriptures have some interesting suggestions on domestic discipline that no one is comfortable talking about.  I am not talking about toxic masculinity or doormat spouses. Like all things, it must be consensual on both sides.

The breakdown comes from two things: women are teaching other women about the submission side of things, while men are teaching other men about the dominant side.  Women are better at being specific and giving full reasons.  This is why a huge majority of good teachers are women. Men are not good at specifics and reasons. They are horrible at it.  This is especially true when anything about communication in a relationship comes up.  A good number of men think you talk about a relationship when you start it and when you end it.  This is why one side is being taught well. At the same time, the other side gets a few platitudes with no specifics on how to handle a submissive, lead effectively, or communicate to ensure consensual power-exchange roles.

The Purity Paradox hits, and women are shamed for wanting to submit, and men are hounded for being dominant.  Women are willing to try, but men have no idea what to tell them to do.  Submissives hate having to top!  They weren’t too sure about it in the first place,e and if they have to lead it all, then what’s the point? This leads to a great deal of frustration on both sides.

I’ve had a few candid conversations with women who admitted they just wished their husbands would give them a good spanking once in a while.  This was before I became openly honest about who I am.  Were they ever comfortable enough to express it to their significant others?  No.  It’s the Purity Paradox again.  

I’ve heard a line dozens of times from religious leaders, from one man to another:  “Whatever goes on behind closed doors between a husband and wife is their business as long as they agree.”  Some religions tack on that last part about agreement; some do not.  This is a great example of a platitude taught from one man to another, but it does no good.  It’s subtle, and men do not get subtle.  I’m not even sure the leaders get the subtext.  None of this helps if both sides aren’t properly educated in what to do.

Where does this proper education come from?  Not Sunday School.  No, the best education in power exchange roles comes from the kink community.  The kink community is not acceptable under the paradox.  We are left with people taking shelter in reading, watching, and listening to vicariously experience the things they want to enjoy in real life.

Like my illustration at the beginning, I wonder how many relationships would still be doing well if one couldn’t just hand their hairbrush to the other and go over their knee.  The hairbrush holder can be the husband or the wife, as long as they agree to what they want.

Leave a Reply