AI art by me. “Cindy’s Choice”

The smell of the grilling steaks was delicious, but it wasn’t what was making David’s mouth water.   He watched the two young women at work in the kitchen through the window.  Sadly, he could only see the top halves, but he remembered the bottom parts well.

They’d come home from the market all giggles and smiles.  Well, they’d been that way when they came into his work office.  

“Hi, Daddy.” Teri grinned at him.

“Hello, Sir.” Cindy blushed a little at calling him that in person.

He eyed her.  “What happened to ‘Daddy?’”

She flushed further.  “Oh, you caught that.”

“I did.  You want to take it back?” He asked.

Cindy shrugged.  “For now, maybe?”

He nodded.  “It’s fine.  I’ll come start getting the meat ready for the grill.  They’ll need to marinate for a little while.”

“They aren’t what’s been marinating for a while, Daddy.” Teri giggled and bit her lower lip.

“Oh? And what should we do about that?” He asked as he rose.

The girls were exchanging very naughty looks.

“You did say you needed to get the meat ready, so maybe we should do the same with…ours?” Teri began to unbutton her blouse and walked away.  Cindy followed right after her.

David sighed in contentment.  It was good to be Daddy.  Walking into the kitchen, he was happy to see the good cuts of steak Teri had bought.  She had a good eye for…well…good meat.  He got out the necessary things to get them in a good marinade that would make them melt in the mouth.

“May we start on the sides, Daddy?” Teri asked softly from behind him.

He turned to see a sight to behold.  

Teri and Cindy were kneeling at the doorway to the kitchen with their heads bowed in respect.  Teri was wearing the black, lacy bralet and thong she knew he really liked.  It was barely there, and yet it made her more naked than being without it.  

Cindy was in a green set that was very similar, and the colors set her off very well.  His curiosity was very piqued to find out if she was bare or had a small strip or a bush.  It wasn’t visible, yet he had hopes.

“Hmm…turn.” He commanded.

Both women obeyed and pivoted on their knees.  Teri was already beginning to move when he told them, “heads down.”  He was impressed that Cindy hadn’t even hesitated a bit.  

Now with their very bare asses in the air, he could see the soft, black line of Teri’s hair and, yes, there was a reddish line showing under Cindy’s thong.  

“Well…I think that meat needs a little tenderizing before starting on the sides.” He commented.

Soft whimpers came from both of the kneeling forms.  

“Daddy, please?  Not the spoon?  Please?” Teri begged.  She hated it!

“Well, that depends…how quickly can you each be up and bent over…” He stopped.

Obviously, Teri had given Cindy an idea of how things worked in the kitchen because, before he was done with the sentence, the girls had dashed over to bend down over the counter of the island in the vast kitchen.  

“Ready, Daddy.” Teri huffed.

“Ready…Daddy.” Cindy whispered and wriggled.

David took his time and went over.  “Eyes closed.”

A faint whimper sounded in stereo, but they obeyed.  Lack of sight would make it even harder to anticipate and heighten the sensations.  He grabbed a small bottle nearby and applied some liquid to his palm.

Teri was dying!  She’d been so hot and wet all day.  Daddy was enjoying this a little too much!  

“Ohhh.” Teri moaned as she felt the oil on his hand begin to caress and knead her arched bottom.  Daddy was a big meanie.  Oiling her bottom would make the spanking twice as stingy, and he knew it!  He’d better oil Cindy’s, too!!

David began to spank his wife slowly and then sped it up.  He delivered hard spanks all over, then really focused on her sit spots.  

Teri was beginning to squirm and feel a prickly sensation in her eyes, just before tears welled up.  Was he going to take her that far?  She’d wait and see.  

He hadn’t decided if he wanted to do what he usually would if it were just her.  She’d said she was a needy little slut earlier, so he’d know a good spanking only made it worse.  She’d love him to slip his finger or two into her and let her release, after sufficient begging.  

Teri felt his fingers move in a very familiar way and knew where he was going.  She let a long, soft moan and shamelessly begged.

“Please, Daddy?” She murmured.

“Please, what?” He asked.

She groaned.  “Ohh, Daddy.  You know!”

His fingers began to rub up and down her swelling labia.  It was driving her crazy!

“Have to use your words, Babygirl.” He commanded.

Teri whimpered once but was past caring.  “Please, Daddy, finger me to death?  Right now? Please?” She sounded very desperate even to her own ears.

David had been listening carefully and didn’t miss the deep, soft moan coming from Cindy behind him.  This was going as he had hoped.

Teri hadn’t heard Cindy.  She hadn’t heard anything at all!  Her Daddy was reaming her with two fingers without any warm-up.  She hadn’t needed it!  All the flirting and Cindy and…and…oh GOD.  

He smiled as he began to hear the sounds he loved bring out of Teri.  Those shameless, slutty, nasty sounds no woman would ever want to admit they made!  Or maybe they would?

Teri began to beg and beg hard!  She knew her Daddy would make her anyway, so she let the sound of the near tears be heard as she pleaded to cum.

“You may.” He told her.

Teri wasn’t quiet.  She’d never been quiet.  It was why they had to carry a ball gag with them when they traveled so that she wouldn’t die of mortification after each night in their hotel room.

David let her slowly come back down, then murmured, “Up, kiss me.”

Teri moved fast and clutched her man, her Daddy, so tight!  She kissed him as deeply as she could, but knew he’d take over…and he did.  Oh, he did!

Cindy was a bit of a mess, hearing all of this just a few inches away.  It was torture!  Yes, it was sweet torture, but still!  Did Sir…or Daddy…know what this was doing to her?  Is it why Teri had gone first?  Of course, she’d go first.  She was his wife, Silly Cindy.

Cindy heard a soft pat of a hand on her bottom.

“Go start working.” He was telling Teri.  “It’s Cindy’s turn.”

Cindy’s heart began to beat so fast and so hard.  She felt his right hand on the small of her back.

“Cindy, would you say you are still rational and not in some kind of subspace yet?” He asked.

“Yes, Sir.” She answered with some curiosity.  Why was he asking this?

“I wanted to be sure before I ask this question.  Are you ready?” He patted her lower back.

She wanted him to pat her bottom!  “Yes, Sir.” She answered.

“You heard and know what I did to Teri.  Should I do all the same to you, or should we wait a bit, and I’ll only spank you?”  He paused.  “I suppose I should ask if that’s okay, too, since I don’t want to assume or not be sure of your full consent.”

Cindy smiled even though he couldn’t see.  This was all about making sure of her full consent before he ever laid a hand on her more than on her lower back.  She wasn’t vain, but she knew what she looked like and was impressed Sir could be so controlled.  It spoke well of him and his respect for her.

David waited for her response, but he also could see the goosebumps break out on her back and thighs.  It foretold what her answer would be.

“Please, Daddy, be…for tonight at least, be my Daddy?  Spank me well, and I want all the rest of it.  Oh, I really do.  I…I…I wanted you since I saw you when you moved in two weeks ago.” She confessed.

Now, she felt his left hand cup and pat her bottom.  “Is that so?” He smacked a little hard.  “Is that why you came over to make friends with Teri?”

Cindy whimpered.

David got more oil and began to prepare her bottom as she answered.

“Yes and no.  I did want a new girlfriend.  I’ve been rather lonely and yes, I wanted to be closer to you, Daddy.” She sighed.  “Am I in trouble?”

David chuckled.  “Nothing a good spanking can’t cure.”

He took his time starting her spanking as he got used to her curves and firmness.  Her ass was different than Teri’s in some subtle ways.  The arch was more dramatic, but the cheeks were more oval than round because of the hips.  It was a delightful bottom to spank!

Cindy sighed and moaned.  It had been so very long since she’d had a good spanking!  The very few times she’d tried to find someone to Top, it hadn’t gone very well.  Nearly all of them were either too soft or too domineering.

She felt the power in Daddy’s hand but also remembered the respect he’d had for her wishes and consent.  This allowed her to trust him and let go.

The truth was that David spanked Cindy harder than Teri, but it was because he just didn’t want to stop!  Cindy squirmed and bounced, but also helped out more with being spanked.  It was hard to explain.  He didn’t need to look to know Teri was watching.  Of course, she’d be watching.

Teri saw that Cindy was getting it worse than she had.  This pleased her greatly that Cindy would be more sore and might even get to tears.  Teri also knew it had more to do with Daddy enjoying himself than anything else, but she’d know he was going to feel this way.  A part of her still wondered how she was going to take it as she watched her Daddy finger fuck another woman.

Cindy felt David’s fingers begin to tease her, and she growled before she moaned.  Daddy knew what he was doing.  He knew really well what he was doing as he rubbed, poked, teased, and made her dance on the countertop.  Cindy just let herself go and become the dirty slut she knew she was inside.

The growls and moans Cindy was making were even turning Teri on a little bit.  She hesitated but lightly stepped up to Daddy’s right side.

“Please, Daddy, please, may I touch myself while I watch?”  She whispered.

Daddy looked towards her and nodded with a smirk.

Teri felt the blush but didn’t care—just one more question to ask.

“Am I allowed to cum if I get there, Daddy?” She asked.

He didn’t even hesitate, but nodded.  Ooo, Daddy was so good to her!

It was so very different when a Daddy fucked you than when you fucked yourself, Cindy was thinking as she began to beg loudly to cum.  

“Hmm…since this is your first…I want to get it clear…are you a slut for me, Cindy?” He growled.

She whimpered.  “Such a needy, dirty slut for you, Daddy. Yes!”

“No shame at all?” He teased.

“NONE!  Please, Daddy.  You can fuck me in the middle of the market with a cucumber if you wish, but let me cum, please???” She pleaded.

“Be careful, Little Girl.  I’ll remember that.” He told her.  “You may cum.”

Cindy squealed in delight and came so very hard and louder than Teri had.  It had been so very long!!

He nearly came himself from having had both the women, but controlled it for now.  Cindy was a little quicker to get back to normal and was quick to obey when he commanded her to kiss him.

Cindy kissed him as best she knew how.  She’d been kissing boys for a while and knew she was good at it.  Her tongue was very agile.

Damn!  David thought as Cindy kissed him and he kissed back.  Her tongue danced with his instead of wrestling.  Her soft noises, which went no further than him, also heated him.

He patted her bottom and sent her to work with Teri.  

Two hushed and submissive-acting women began to prepare the side dishes of mashed potatoes and corn on the cob.  David enjoyed the matching red bottoms wiggling a little as the women worked.  He could also tell that they felt his eyes and were wiggling more than necessary.

He got out the steaks and the tongs.  Just as he was leaving, he watched them compare bottoms with whispers and grins.  It was such an erotic scene when he was the one who had spanked them both.

All this came ot his mind as he remembered well the bottom parts he couldn’t see but had enjoyed thoroughly before coming out to grill.  The steaks were ready, and Teri gave him a thumbs-up to confirm they were prepared.

He went inside, and neither woman would let him do a thing.  They took the steaks and had him sit down to be waited upon.  It was a lovely dinner.  The way the girls squirmed slightly as they ate and chatted with each other and him was very entertaining.  

As things began to close in, David noticed they started sharing those naughty looks again.  “Okay, what did you two talk about or plan this time?” He asked.

They froze, looking at him and then at each other.  A shrug passed between them, and Cindy nodded to Teri.

“Well, we didn’t get any dessert at the market, which is horrible.” Teri’s voice emphasized this.  “We were thinking…we have some chocolate syrup and some whipped cream, so…we wanted to make you the dessert, Daddy.” She grinned.

(All for now, but we’ll return to them at some point.)